Tradition in Every Slice

Sammy's Pizzeria has been proudly family owned and operated for three generations. Founded in 1962 by Sammy Musolino, we're the home of the original Half Tray Pizza — a tradition that has become a staple in our community and a go-to choice for family dinners, parties, and gatherings throughout Niagara Falls.

From our signature pizzas to hearty pasta dishes and classic Buffalo wings, everything we serve is made with the same care that's kept customers coming back decade after decade. We're a neighborhood favorite for generations, and we're proud to keep that tradition going.

Whether you're dining in with us, picking up a Half Tray for game night, or ordering delivery to your door, Sammy's is here to serve you the food Niagara Falls knows and loves.

Our menu has something for everyone. Here are a few of the items our customers come back for again and again:

• Half Tray Pizza — 15 square-cut slices of our signature tray-style pizza, starting at $14.75. Perfect for sharing.
• Buffalo Wings — Served with celery and bleu cheese. Available in orders of 14, 20, 30, or 50 pieces.
• New York Style Pie — Personal size starting at $4.99, with medium and large options available.
• Steak and Cheese Sub — Loaded with lettuce, tomato, onions, and cheese.
• Specialty Pizzas — Including Buffalo Chicken Pizza, 716 Pizza, Old Fashioned Pizza, and more.

We also serve strombolis, calzones, pasta dinners, salads, wraps, appetizers, and desserts. Gluten-free pizza crust and pizza bowls are available too.

In-House Full Bar: Enjoy craft cocktails, beer, and wine with your meal in our comfortable dining room.

Carry-Out & Delivery: Order online and enjoy our food at home with fast pickup or local delivery throughout Niagara Falls and nearby neighborhoods.

Large Banquet Room: Our spacious banquet room is perfect for birthday parties, graduation celebrations, business meetings, sports banquets, and family gatherings of all sizes.